Coldwell Banker Schmitt

My Info

Carol Brenn

85996 Overseas Highway
Islamorada, FL 33036
(305) 664-4470
(305) 393-0935
(305) 664-4111
My Website
85996 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036


WELCOME TO ISLAMORADA! It would be my pleasure to use Coldwell Banker's vast resources & my background & experience to meet your real estate needs.

Service Areas & Specialties

  • Residential waterfront properties
  • Condominiums and mobile homes
  • New homes
  • Investment
  • Relocation - Vacation - Second Homes - Retirement


  • 15 years Education and Marketing experience with IBM Corporation
  • Licensed Realtor since 1987
  • Masters degree in Business Education 
  • Graduate Realtor Institute; Certified eMarketing Specialist
  • Member of the Florida Association of Realtors; Member of the Florida Keys Boards of Realtors; Education Committee Chairman for FKBR


  • Multi-Million Dollar Sales Achievement Awards
  • Certificate of Appreciation -- Upper Keys Board of Realtors Education Committee Chairman
  • Director - Upper Keys Board of Realtors 2010-2011

Professional Experience

  • Licensed Realtor since 1987
  • Graduate Realtor Institute
  • 26 year resident of Islamorada & Upper Keys Board of Realtors
  • 3 year resident of Key West 

Professional Education and Designations

  • Masters degree in Business
  • Extensive marketing background with IBM

What my clients are saying (9)

08/14/2017 - Thomas & Catherine Lenoir

Carol Brenn was a dream to work with! Extremely calm & decisive. Excellent communicator! She held our hands every step of the way and was so dependable, that our sale & transition was totally stress free - best experience ever! We are happy clients.

10/05/2015 - Michael Haney

Carol did an outstanding job with my recent purchase. She went above and beyond and never stopped fighting for me to make sure the difficult deal (bank owned home) went through! It would not have happened without her. I couldn't be more pleased and would use her again!

07/01/2015 - Bernie Holzman

Carol was the hardest working, most thorough and most professional agent we've worked with in the process of selling our property. The process was arduous and full of false starts because of the unique nature of the property, and the peculiarities of the buyers. Carol never gave up and did everything possible to make the deal happen. And it did. We would use her services again, in a heartbeat, and would recommend her to anyone contemplating a real estate transaction.

11/27/2013 - lylekrad

Carol's years of experience and knowledge was invaluable!
Her local knowledge is also something you can not duplicate!
Combine this with her willingness to go the extra mile and find properties that fit what we were looking for, not just what was easy found us the perfect house. She is also a very kind person with no agenda.
If you want the perfect house in the Keys,go to Carol!

10/11/2012 - user1912979

I have dealt with Carol for the last 12 years and she has helped me complete at least a half a dozen sales,this includes working as both a buying and selling agent.

Carol is meticulous in researching details about properties and works very hard to ensure her clients needs are met. I have recommended Carol to friends and suggest that any one who decides to work with Carol will be well served.

10/01/2012 - user967448

For 6 months she helped to look for a condo/ house, finally when I decided to buy a house she was very responsive to my requests and after looking at multiple houses she suggested one that was outside my price range, I loved it, she then negotiated a price that was good for me and helped me to find financing
She is a great real state agent
I will be forever thankful

10/01/2012 - user4753397

Carol has been in the business a long time and is very professional. She gives you one on one time and you always feel she is on your side. Always available to answer your questions and give you advice. You will get the personal touch with Carol.

10/01/2012 - user5666192

I recently purchased a house through Carol in Islamorada. The process took six months due to seller issues and Carol was always there to offer her support and expertise. Carol even helped my wife and I find a place to stay when we sold our property and were expecting a closing that was delayed. Carol is a lot more than a realtor, she will support you as a friend would. This was not my first home purchase but it was more involved than the last six houses put together. Thank goodness I had Carol, if it wasn't for her I would have passed on this deal. My wife and I are now very happy with our purchase!

09/26/2012 - user8545412

Carol has successfully sold two of my properties and was able to get me the best and highest price. She efficiently processed my sales without any problems. I am looking forward to future dealings through Carol Brenn.

Active Listings (1)

Property Address Details Price
76340 Overseas Highway, Lower Matecumbe, FL 33036 - Lower Matecumbe, FL real estate listing
76340 Overseas Highway
Lower Matecumbe, FL 33036
2 Bed(s) | 2 Total Bath(s) | 1,460 SqFt$2,150,000

Recent Listings Sold (2)

Property Address Details
98222 Windward Avenue #9822
Key Largo, FL 33037
2 Bed(s) | 2 Total Bath(s) | 778 SqFt
83201 Old Highway #308
Upper Matecumbe Key Islamorada, FL 33036
2 Bed(s) | 2 Total Bath(s) | 1,275 SqFt

Recent Buyer Sales (2)

Property Address Details
100 4th Lane
Key Largo, FL 33037
3 Bed(s) | 2 Total Bath(s) | 1,728 SqFt
130 Coral Avenue
Plantation Key, FL 33070
3 Bed(s) | 2 Total Bath(s) | 1,478 SqFt

Contact Me


Real Estate Links Our Domains