My Info
Caitlin McKinney
Marathon, FL 33050
(305) 743-5181
Florida Keys Realtor® | Coldwell Banker Schmitt Real Estate
Caitlin McKinney is a full-time Florida Keys Realtor® with Coldwell Banker Schmitt Real Estate. With over a decade of experience, she’s known for well-informed guidance and clear communication—keeping clients confident and supported from the first conversation through closing.
Caitlin works with both local homeowners and out-of-town clients across the Upper, Middle, and Lower Keys, assisting with primary residences, second homes, and investment properties. Her approach is steady and detail-forward, with an organized process and careful follow-through at every step—especially when navigating the unique details of homeownership in the Keys.
Qualifications
Full-time Florida Keys Realtor® | Over a decade of experience
Upper | Middle | Lower Keys
Primary residences | Second homes | Investment properties
Local homeowners | Out-of-town clients
Well-informed guidance | Clear communication
Organized, detail forward process with careful follow-through
Well-versed in the unique details of Florida Keys homeownership
Credentials
Florida Real Estate License | SL#3348825
Realtor® | Florida Association of Realtors®
Realtor® | National Association of Realtors®
Honors & Leadership
Rising Star | Coldwell Banker Schmitt (2016)
Rookie of the Year | Marathon & Lower Keys Association of REALTORS® (2017)
Realtor® of the Year | Marathon & Lower Keys Association of REALTORS® (2019)
International Diamond Society | Coldwell Banker (2022)
International President’s Award | Coldwell Banker (2024)
Marathon & Lower Keys Association of Realtors® | Board of Directors (2017–2025)
• President-Elect (2019) | President (2020) | Secretary (2021)
What my clients are saying (8)
My Service Ratings
03/03/2021 - Dariuse & Teresa K.
Caitlin was a pleasure to work with, very knowledgeable and informative. We will definitely refer her to all our friends and family.
My Service Ratings
09/25/2019 - Richard O. & Karen B.–
“Caitlin is one of the BEST Real Estate Agents we’ve ever had! She is very detail-oriented and perfect in her skills. We can’t believe we were so lucky to find her. We recommended her to our neighbors and friends, we are even selling another property through her.”
My Service Ratings
09/20/2019 - Not Provided
Caitlin is one of the best agents we've ever dealt with, and we've dealt with many of them. She sold our property for us, and we were impressed with her professionalism, ethics, technical skills and process knowledge, and her hard work to ace the process all the way from the listing agreement to the closing of the sale. I highly recommend her. She is the best.
