Coldwell Banker Schmitt

My Info

Caitlin McKinney

 Residential & Commercial 
11050 Overseas Highway
Marathon, FL 33050
(305) 743-5181
(305) 304-7397
(305) 743-7012
caitlin@cbschmitt.com
My Website
11050 Overseas Highway, Marathon, FL 33050

Welcome!

Get your keys by the sea with Caitlin McKinney!

Love of the sun and ocean brought me here from where I grew up, in Missouri. After living a year in the United States Virgin Islands, followed by 5 years in Texas, my family and I found our forever home in the Florida Keys in 2015.

Hobbies: I enjoy being outdoors, boating, kayaking, and snorkeling with my family, seeing new places, experiencing new adventures, and meeting new people.

Education: While in Missouri, I attended the University of Central Missouri with a double major in Early Childhood and Elementary Education. I have since attended the Rowlett School of Real Estate, which prepared me to pass my state licensing exam on the first try.

Work Experience: While in Texas, I co-owned and operated a successful restaurant in the north Fort Worth area. I assisted in creating the restaurant from the ground up, including design and renovation, developing the marketing plan, creating a menu, staffing and training, financials, and overseeing daily operations. After moving to the Florida Keys in 2015, I got my real estate license and started working with Coldwell Banker Schmitt. After a great first 18 months in the business, I was awarded both the "Rising Star" by Coldwell Banker Schmitt and the "Rookie of the Year" by the Marathon and Lower Keys Association of Realtors. I currently sit as a Director on the Marathon and Lower Keys Association of Realtors for the 2017-2019 term.

As an Agent: I am a motivated, full-time agent working on the Sam Williams' Team, under the #1 top producing agent in the Middle Keys since 2012. When you choose to work with me, you will get both of us working to ensure your deal is as seamless as possible from listing, to contract and negotiations, through closing and beyond. As your agent, I will make your goals my focus; I will remain responsive, communicative, honest, and informative every step of the way. I put great pride into my superior customer service skills and the amount of work I do for each of my clients, as I go above and beyond in my extensive due diligence work to keep my client best informed and protected. I can assist in all of your residential real estate needs through the Upper, Middle, and Lower Keys markets. Whether you are buying or selling, from near and far, I will work with you to make sure your experience an enjoyable one! 

Honors & Awards

  • Awarded the "Rising Star" in 2016 by Coldwell Banker Schmitt
  • Awarded the "Rookie of the Year" in 2017 by the Marathon & Lower Keys Association of Realtors
  • Director on Board of Directors of Marathon and Lower Keys Association of Realtors for 2017-2019
  • Member of the Florida Association of Realtors®
  • Member of the National Association of Realtors®
  • Realtor with the #1 Company in Listing and Sales Since 2004!

What my clients are saying (1)

01/13/2018 - Doresay

Choosing Caitlyn McKinney as our realtor was the best decision we made when looking to purchase a condo in the Keys! Caitlin guided us over several hurdles and always had a smile. She is professional and extremely knowledgeable. Caitlin made us feel like we were her only clients no matter how often we called or texted. She took the time to research the properties so we were fully informed. She went above and beyond what we expected from a realtor. If you are looking to buy or sell, your first step should be a call to Caitlin McKinney. Best decision we made was trusting Caitlin to assist us with our purchase!

Active Listings (3)

1057 68th Street, Marathon, FL 33050 - Marathon, FL real estate listing
3 Bed(s) | 1 Total Bath(s) | 1,595 SqFt
$749,000
6099 Overseas Highway #111E, Marathon, FL 33050 - Marathon, FL real estate listing
R-MH - Residential - MH Zoning | 0.02 Acre(s)
$108,000
12411 Overseas Highway #33A, Marathon, FL 33050 - Marathon, FL real estate listing
0 Bed(s) | 0 Total Bath(s) | 0 SqFt
$64,500

Recent Listings Sold (25)

Property Address Details
161 3rd Street
Key Colony, FL 33051
2 Bed(s) | 2 Total Bath(s) | 1,433 SqFt
115 Stirrup Key Woods Road #4a1
Marathon, FL 33050
2 Bed(s) | 2 Total Bath(s) | 1,176 SqFt
57423 Goodley Street
Marathon, FL 33050
3 Bed(s) | 2 Total Bath(s) | 1,300 SqFt
65821 Overseas Highway #231
Long Key, FL 33001
2 Bed(s) | 2 Total Bath(s) | 816 SqFt
605 Sombrero Beach Road #202
Marathon, FL 33050
2 Bed(s) | 1 Total Bath(s) | 755 SqFt
11339 5th Avenue Ocean
Marathon, FL 33050
2 Bed(s) | 1 Total Bath(s) | 1,096 SqFt
15 Kingfisher Lane
Key West, FL 33040
3 Bed(s) | 3 Total Bath(s) | 1,320 SqFt
1111 30th Street Ocean
Marathon, FL 33050
3 Bed(s) | 2 Total Bath(s) | 1,296 SqFt
570 97th Street Ocean
Marathon, FL 33050
4 Bed(s) | 3 Total Bath(s) | 2,210 SqFt
837 91st Court Ocean
Marathon, FL 33050
2 Bed(s) | 2 Total Bath(s) | 1,296 SqFt
9640 Aviation Boulevard
Marathon, FL 33050
2 Bed(s) | 2 Total Bath(s) | 836 SqFt
999 98th Street #5
Marathon, FL 33050
1 Bed(s) | 2 Total Bath(s) | 813 SqFt
11 Sombrero Boulevard #12e
Marathon, FL 33050
1 Bed(s) | 1 Total Bath(s) | 647 SqFt
12690 Overseas Highway #23
Marathon, FL 33050
2 Bed(s) | 3 Total Bath(s) | 1,387 SqFt
1 Transferable Building Right
Marathon, FL 33050
RM - Residential Medium Zoning | 0.00 Acre(s)
7550 Gulfstream Boulevard
Marathon, FL 33050
2 Bed(s) | 2 Total Bath(s) | 1,549 SqFt
1199 73rd Street Ocean
Marathon, FL 33050
2 Bed(s) | 1 Total Bath(s) | 768 SqFt
109 Avenue D #303
Marathon, FL 33050
2 Bed(s) | 2 Total Bath(s) | 925 SqFt
2000 Overseas Highway #g1
Marathon, FL 33050
3 Bed(s) | 2 Total Bath(s) | 1,650 SqFt
1 Transferable Building Right
Marathon, FL 33050
RM - Residential Medium Zoning | 0.00 Acre(s)
115 Stirrup Key Woods Road #4b1
Marathon, FL 33050
2 Bed(s) | 2 Total Bath(s) | 1,176 SqFt
10950 5th Avenue Ocean
Marathon, FL 33050
2 Bed(s) | 2 Total Bath(s) | 1,248 SqFt
2000 Coco Plum Drive #804
Marathon, FL 33050
1 Bed(s) | 2 Total Bath(s) | 737 SqFt
146 N Indies Drive
Duck Key, FL 33050
3 Bed(s) | 2 Total Bath(s) | 1,640 SqFt
396 25th St Ocean
Marathon, FL 33050
3 Bed(s) | 2 Total Bath(s) | 1,000 SqFt

Recent Buyer Sales (14)

Property Address Details
161 3rd Street
Key Colony, FL 33051
2 Bed(s) | 2 Total Bath(s) | 1,433 SqFt
212 E Bruce Court
Marathon, FL 33050
3 Bed(s) | 3 Total Bath(s) | 1,713 SqFt
654 W 105th Street Ocean Street Ocean
Marathon, FL 33050
3 Bed(s) | 2 Total Bath(s) | 1,232 SqFt
304 N Anglers Drive
Marathon, FL 33050
9 Bed(s) | 6 Total Bath(s) | 4,144 SqFt
868 73rd Street Ocean Street
Marathon, FL 33050
3 Bed(s) | 1 Total Bath(s) | 1,424 SqFt
58589 Morton Street
Marathon, FL 33050
3 Bed(s) | 2 Total Bath(s) | 1,144 SqFt
2797 Overseas Highway
Marathon, FL 33050
0 Story(s) | 2,520 SqFt | 0 Office SqFt
12400 Overseas Highway #12
Marathon, FL 33050
3 Bed(s) | 3 Total Bath(s) | 1,493 SqFt
303 Sombrero Boulevard #209
Marathon, FL 33050
1 Bed(s) | 1 Total Bath(s) | 587 SqFt
203 Peachtree Avenue
Marathon, FL 33050
3 Bed(s) | 2 Total Bath(s) | 1,456 SqFt
11 Blue Isle Boulevard
Marathon, FL 33050
3 Bed(s) | 3 Total Bath(s) | 2,032 SqFt
19 St Martin Lane
Ramrod Key, FL 33042
3 Bed(s) | 2 Total Bath(s) | 1,241 SqFt
450 122nd Street Ocean
Marathon, FL 33050
2 Bed(s) | 2 Total Bath(s) | 1,226 SqFt
540 96th Street Ocean
Marathon, FL 33050
2 Bed(s) | 1 Total Bath(s) | 1,200 SqFt

Contact Us

v-card

Real Estate Links Our Domains