My Info
Nancy Hershoff
Islamorada, FL 33036
(305) 664-4470
Growing up in Miami, my family and I were always in the Keys. We crabbed on Card Sound Road, fished and shrimped in the Upper Keys and was taught to filet and cook what we caught. My father also taught me the importance of conservation. Only take what you need to eat. I caught a White Marlin, fought for 1 hour and 33 minutes, tagged, and released it, off Islamorada. Although I have several degrees including a master’s in health care administration, I love being a realtor. Helping people to sell or buy homes to achieve their goals is so important. Guiding them through and being informed of the real estate process so they have the least amount of stress is what I strive for. I am so proud to say I live in the FL Keys. I have been here full time for 26 years and want to continue living and working here in paradise.
What my clients are saying (10)
My Service Ratings
03/17/2026 - Janet A.
I listed my house with Coldwell Banker Schmitt because of Nancy Hershoff. Nancy is a hard worker; she held frequent open houses and was able to make a very knowledgeable presentation of the property. She knows all the details because she cared to the best job possible.
My Service Ratings
11/27/2019 - Nikki Griffin
Nancy found and negotiated an off market property for my family. We closed my VA loan in less than 27 days! Very responsive and professional!Matt Bussard
My Service Ratings
05/11/2017 - Not Provided
Nancy was a pleasure to work with. She managed the sale of our property with extreme professionalism and expertise. She accurately set the value of our house, put together a great marketing plan, communicated frequently and negotiated a complex deal with a difficult buyer and buyer realtor for us. As a long time resident of the Keys, Nancy knows the islands well (good locations, poor locations, etc). She was a pleasure to work with and I would highly recommend her if you are looking for a new home in the Keys or selling yours.
Active Listings (5)
| Property Address | Details |
|---|---|
 Conch, FL 33050 | Story(s) | 0 sqft | 0 Office SqFt |
 Key Largo, FL 33037 | Bed(s): 3 Bath(s): 3 sqft: 1,716 |
 Key Largo, FL 33037 | Bed(s): 3 Bath(s): 3 sqft: 1,716 |
 Islamorada, FL 33036 | is Zoning | 0.15 Acre(s) |
 Islamorada, FL 33036 | R1 - Residential Single Family Zoning | 0.15 Acre(s) |
Recent Listings Sold (11)
| Property Address | Details |
|---|---|
 Islamorada, FL 33036 | Bed(s): 3 Bath(s): 3 sqft: 3,458 |
 Islamorada, FL 33036 | Story(s) | 1,566 sqft | 0 Office SqFt |
 Key Largo, FL 33037 | Bed(s): 4 Bath(s): 2 sqft: 1,665 |
 Islamorada, FL 33036 | Bed(s): 4 Bath(s): 3 sqft: 1,710 |
 Islamorada, FL 33036 | Bed(s): 3 Bath(s): 3 sqft: 1,440 |
 Homestead, FL 33030 | Bed(s): 4 Bath(s): 2 sqft: 1,848 |
 Key Largo, FL 33070 | Bed(s): 0 Bath(s): 0 sqft: 800 |
 Key Largo, FL 33070 | Bed(s): 1 Bath(s): 1 |
 Key Largo, FL 33037 | Bed(s): 1 Bath(s): 1 sqft: 800 |
 Key Largo, FL 33070 | Bed(s): 1 Bath(s): 1 |
 Key Largo, FL 33070 | Bed(s): 0 Bath(s): 0 |
Recent Buyer Sales (6)
| Property Address | Details |
|---|---|
 Long Key, FL 33001 | Bed(s): 2 Bath(s): 2 sqft: 999 |
 Marathon, FL 33050 | Bed(s): 0 Bath(s): 0 |
Key Largo, FL 33070 | Bed(s): 0 Bath(s): 0 sqft: 800 |
Key Largo, FL 33070 | Bed(s): 1 Bath(s): 1 |
Key Largo, FL 33070 | Bed(s): 1 Bath(s): 1 |
Key Largo, FL 33070 | Bed(s): 0 Bath(s): 0 |