My Info

Caroline Wagner-Earles

SL3314785

Realtor

(305) 849-1058

(305) 872-4220

carolinecoldwellbs@gmail.com

My Website

Download My Contact Information

Big Pine Key Office

29967 Overseas Highway
Big Pine Key, FL 33043
(305) 872-3050

Welcome

Welcome to the Fabulous Florida Keys and Coldwell Banker Schmitt Real Estate, celebrating over 60 years of professional service in the Keys! An incredible Tropical Paradise... I will assist you and manage your Transaction to Closing... Resident of Florida Keys for 24 years - Let me "get to work" for you.

About

Initially from New Jersey, moved to the Keys in 1998, spending the last 24 years enjoying the Tropical Florida Keys!
Over 25 years of Sales, Marketing, Management, and Media experience. Extended knowledge of Florida Keys areas
Sold properties: Cudjoe Key, Ramrod, Big Pine, Marathon, Little Torch & Key West- approximately $13 million sold.

Expertise

Extensive knowledge of Florida Keys, Middle Keys, Lower Keys, and Key West areas

Credentials

Over 35 years of Sales, Marketing, Media and Management, and Operations experience

Qualifications

Member National Association of Realtors (NAR)
Member Marathon and Lower Keys Association of Realtors (MLKAR)
Member of Florida Association of Realtors Lic#SL3314785

What my clients are saying (10)

My Service Ratings

03/17/2026 - Kimberly B.

Caroline is terrific to work with! She is knowledgeable and helped me to keep an open mind which led to finding & purchasing this home. She is down to earth and has fantastic follow up skills.

My Service Ratings

10/18/2022 - Melton Properties, LLC

Caroline was FABULOUS!

My Service Ratings

12/03/2020 - Carlyle & Loretta B. - Sellers

“I would not hesitate to recommend Coldwell Banker Schmitt for any real estate transaction in the Keys. Caroline Wagner-Earles was friendly, knowledgeable, and professional throughout the whole process. Thank you all very much.”

My Service Ratings

11/05/2020 - Marie & John G.- Buyers

“Overall excellent service.”

My Service Ratings

10/06/2019 - Paul & Laura

Carolyn Wagner-Earles helped us purchase our home in Big Pine Key, Florida this year. We began looking for home in February and met Cal at an open house. We immediately developed a great rapport with her - she is easy to talk to and really wanted to help us find a house that we both loved. She was patient and worked really hard to fit lots of showing into limited time periods to accommodate our schedule. Cal has the great knowledge of the Real Estate market in the Lower Keys. She understands the strengths and weaknesses of the various neighborhoods, and showed us a nice variety of homes at various price points so that we could develop a good working knowledge of the market, which is so very important when you are buying homes in the Keys. We Finally found the right home in September and Cal coordinated a seamless closing. We are very happy with our new home, and we would recommend Cal to anyone searching for a home in the Lowers Keys. Thanks Cal!

My Service Ratings

06/26/2019 - David & Marybeth S

We met Caroline (Cal) at on an open house and were immediately impressed by her professionalism and personality. When we decided to look at a house being sold by another realtor we knew we wanted Cal to represent our interests. She is honest and sincere! ”

My Service Ratings

03/13/2018 - Suzy M.

We also have friends we referred to you...
...We gave you ALL the raves and fanfare about how you kept us on track with deadlines and how you listened to us by showing us all the properties we wanted to see, and going the extra mile (literally) by picking me up and the dog at MM 68 convenience store!!! They loved the stories!

My Service Ratings

02/25/2018 - Kimberly B.

“This was a long and difficult process because of the hurricane and also because the condo association was new and the previous one did not have proper legal documentation. Carline worked with me each step and was patient and understanding with my banks requests. Thanks for her help! I’m not sure this purchase would have happened without her help. She was always available and responsive.”

My Service Ratings

11/22/2017 - Eugent & Pam D.

"My husband and I just clicked with Cal. Went to an open house she was doing and liked her honesty and bubbly personality. She is now a friend and neighbor."

My Service Ratings

07/14/2017 - Paul & Laura L

“Cal was a great realtor to work with and we would recommend her to anyone we know who was purchasing in the Lower Keys.”
.

Recent Listings Sold (5)

Property Address	Details
1964 Coral Way Big Pine, FL 33043	Bed(s): 2 Bath(s): 3 sqft: 1,040
650 11th Street Key Colony, FL 33051	Bed(s): 3 Bath(s): 3 sqft: 1,770
369 Lafitte Road Little Torch, FL 33042	Bed(s): 1 Bath(s): 1 sqft: 1,248
580 Blackbeard Road Little Torch, FL 33042	Bed(s): 2 Bath(s): 2 sqft: 1,212
0 John Silver Road Little Torch Key, FL 33042	IS - Improved Subivision Distric Zoning \| 0.16 Acre(s)

Recent Buyer Sales (6)

Property Address	Details
20730 1st Avenue Cudjoe, FL 33042	Bed(s): 3 Bath(s): 2 sqft: 1,948
1092 Bay Drive Summerland, FL 33042	Bed(s): 3 Bath(s): 2 sqft: 1,611
24394 W Caribbean Drive Summerland, FL 33042	Bed(s): 2 Bath(s): 3 sqft: 1,200
1121 Coates Lane Cudjoe, FL 33042	Bed(s): 2 Bath(s): 2 sqft: 960
300 3rd Street Key Colony, FL 33051	Bed(s): 2 Bath(s): 2 sqft: 1,031
3312 Northside Drive, 511 Key West, FL 33040	Bed(s): 2 Bath(s): 2 sqft: 792