(305) 743-5181
Connect with us on twitter
Connect with us on facebook
Connect with us on instagram
Connect with us on linkedin
Connect with us on pinterest
Connect with us on youtube
Follow our blog
Home
Search
Property Search
Luxury Island Properties
Our Listings
New Listings
Single Family Homes
Condos & Townhouses
For Lease
Commercial
Lots & Land
Boat Slips
Listings Showcase
Key Largo Showcase
Islamorada Showcase
Middle Keys Showcase
Big Pine Key Showcase
Lower Keys Below Big Pine Key
Key West Showcase
Vacant Land Showcase
Boat Slips Showcase
Neighborhood Info
Key West Neighborhoods
Lower Keys Neighborhoods
Middle Keys Neighborhoods
Islamorada Neighborhoods
Key Largo Neighborhoods
Luxury Island Properties Agents
Open Houses
Open House Events
Open Houses by List Price
Open Houses by Number of Bedrooms
Open Houses by Square Feet
Agents
Residential
Commercial
Coldwell Banker Global Luxury
Elite Agent Circle
Luxury
About Luxury Island Properties
Featured Luxury Island Properties
Find Luxury Island Properties Agents
Coldwell Banker Schmitt's Luxury Island Properties Report
Coldwell Banker Global Luxury
About Coldwell Banker Global Luxury
Coldwell Banker Global Luxury blog
Coldwell Magazine
The Mid-Year Report 2026
Luxury Island Properties Showcase
Luxury Island Properties Showcase Keys-wide
Key West Luxury Island Properties Showcase
Sugarloaf Key to Little Torch Luxury Island Properties Showcase
Big Pine Key Luxury Island Properties Showcase
Marathon Luxury Island Properties Showcase
Key Colony Beach Luxury Island Properties Showcase
Layton-Long Key Luxury Island Properties Showcase
Islamorada Luxury Island Properties Showcase
Tavernier Luxury Island Properties Showcase
Key Largo Luxury Island Properties Showcase
Commercial
CB Schmitt Commercial
Our Commercial Listings For Sale
Commercial Featured Properties
Find Commercial Agents
Commercial Listings Showcase
Coldwell Banker Schmitt's Commercial Report
About Us
About Us
Offices
Our Offices
Key Largo
Islamorada
Middle Keys
Lower Keys
Cudjoe Key
Key West
Our Background
Blog
Charitable Foundation
Coldwell Banker Schmitt Privacy Policy
Resources
What's my home worth?
My Portal
Newsletters
Real Estate Report
Luxury Island Properties Report
Commercial Report
Advice
Buyers Toolkit
Sellers Toolkit
Helpful Links
NAR Code of Ethics
About the Keys
About the Keys
Key Largo
Islamorada
Middle Keys
Lower Keys
Key West
Florida Keys Service Providers Lists
Vacation Rentals
Careers
Contact Us
My Portal
Search
Minimum Price
Maximum Price
Beds Min
Beds Max
Baths Min
Baths Max
Sqfoot Min
Sqfoot Max
Search Listings
Menu
Lower Keys Communities
Bay Point AMD
Bay Point Trlr Pk
Gulf Shores
Indian Mound Estates
Orchid Park sub
Sugarloaf Acres
Sugarloaf Beach
Sugarloaf Shores
Sugarloaf Townsite
Vacation Harbor
19
Listings Available
$1,231
Median Price/Per SqFt
$2,635,000
Median List Price
Listings Stats
Price Range
Percent
Listings Available
Action
$700K - $800K
5.26%
1
View Homes
$900K+
94.74%
18
View Homes
The Sugarloaf Shores subdivision is found between mile markers 16.5 and 17 on Lower Sugarloaf Key's Atlantic side. You'll find listings of residential homes currently for sale below.
SUGARLOAF KEY WEATHER
View Full Details
$
10,499,000
6
bds
8
ba
4,894
sqft
Active
1041 E Buttonwood Drive, Sugarloaf, FL 33042
MLS #: 617664
The Agency Florida Keys
View Full Details
$
5,200,000
4
bds
4
ba
2,660
sqft
Active
17013 Coral Drive, Sugarloaf, FL 33042
MLS #: 618184
Coldwell Banker Schmitt Real Estate Co
View Full Details
$
3,899,000
4
bds
3
ba
2,096
sqft
Active
17015 W Wahoo Lane, Sugarloaf, FL 33042
MLS #: 618713
Coldwell Banker Schmitt Real Estate Co
View Full Details
$
3,750,000
4
bds
4
ba
2,409
sqft
Active
17387 E Dolphin Street, Sugarloaf, FL 33042
MLS #: 619842
Coldwell Banker Schmitt Real Estate Co.
View Full Details
$
3,199,000
4
bds
4
ba
1,744
sqft
Active
17183 Coral Drive, Sugarloaf, FL 33042
MLS #: 618532
Coldwell Banker Schmitt RE Co.
View Full Details
$
2,895,000
4
bds
4
ba
1,804
sqft
Active
17385 Keystone Road, Sugarloaf, FL 33042
MLS #: 618105
The Agency Florida Keys
Real Estate Links
Our Domains